Bailian Group, a major player in the retail industry based in Shanghai, has long been recognized for its significant holdings in premium commercial properties, totaling over two million square meters. These assets represent an invaluable competitive advantage—often referred to as the company's "moat." However, despite its robust property portfolio, the company's financial performance has faced challenges in recent years, particularly with the rise of e-commerce disrupting traditional retail models. What remains intriguing is how the company’s undervalued assets could soon be prominently reappraised.

Founded amidst the economic reforms of the 1980s, Bailian Group has expanded its footprint across various retail formats, including department stores, supermarkets, shopping malls, and outlets. The company is controlled by the Shanghai State-owned Assets Supervision and Administration Commission, a testament to its deeply rooted ties with local governance. Nevertheless, with changing consumer behaviors influenced by digital commerce, the company reported significant declines in both revenue and net profit over the past few years, prompting concerns about its long-term viability.

Advertisement

Between 2019 and 2023, Bailian's revenue saw a substantial drop from 50.5 billion yuan to 30.5 billion yuan. The net profit figures followed a similar downward trend, cumulatively pointing towards significant pressures on profitability. As of late 2023, the company's market capitalization stood at approximately 17 billion yuan, casting doubts on whether the valuation accurately reflected the company's real potential, especially when considering its conservative accounting practices that often undervalue its assets.

A closer examination reveals a stark contrast between the company’s free cash flow and its net profit. Over the past decade, Bailian amassed a net operational cash flow of approximately 27 billion yuan while incurring just over 14 billion yuan in capital expenditures. Consequently, the cash flow generated for shareholder benefits reached roughly 12.6 billion yuan, far exceeding the cumulative net profit of only 5.4 billion yuan for the same period. This discrepancy raises pertinent questions regarding the characterization of Bailian's financial health.

The source of this disparity lies within Bailian's excessively cautious accounting policies. For instance, the company's accounting for depreciation is notably stringent, with a depreciation rate assigned to its fixed assets that significantly misrepresents the longevity and income-generating potential of its commercial properties. In 2023, the company reported a depreciation expense of 944 million yuan, based on an average lifespan assumption of less than 15 years. This significantly underplays the true value of buildings that have often been in operation well beyond two decades, many of which are situated in prime locations.

To demonstrate this point, consider prominent properties like the Shanghai Qingpu Outlet, which has consistently ranked among the top in the nation for nearly 20 years, or properties that opened in the late 1950s still generating revenue today. Their average market condition and positioning could demand valuations far exceeding their current book values.

When projected cash flows are considered, Bailian’s financial outlook appears more favorable. Over the past five years, the company's free cash flow ranged from around 1.1 billion yuan to nearly 3 billion yuan annually, suggesting that investing in the company at its current market price could yield strong returns, especially if free cash flows average about 2 billion yuan in the coming decade.

Looking deeper into the valuation of its real estate assets reveals staggering numbers. By the end of 2023, Bailian's total assets stood at 56.2 billion yuan, with net assets reaching 19.6 billion yuan. The most significant portion of this is fixed assets valued at 14.3 billion yuan, primarily derived from its premier commercial properties located in some of Shanghai's most sought-after districts.

For illustrative purposes, if we were to assess the value of properties in key markets, a rough estimate for 1.2 million square meters in Shanghai priced at 30,000 yuan per square meter would yield a value exceeding 36 billion yuan. Similarly, the revenue potential these properties could generate through rental income could surpass 8 billion yuan annually, creating a compelling narrative for potential investors desperate to uncover hidden value.

Adding to this, the company has recently tapped into real estate investment trusts (REITs) as a vehicle for monetizing its holdings. In 2024, Bailian announced the successful launch of its REIT offerings, particularly with the asset tied to the Yuyuan Shopping Center, which grossed over 2.3 billion yuan—a clear indication of the latent value within the firm's asset base ready to be unlocked.

The burgeoning popularity of REITs could significantly protect Bailian from the downward pressures afflicting traditional retail models. While the company’s operating cash flow was reported at a mere 1.58 billion yuan in contrast to its remarkable 16.2 billion yuan net profit, this split was primarily propelled by investment gains from its REIT endeavors. This triumph has illuminated pathways for future fundraising directed at enhancing their margin-absorbing real estate portfolio.

Moreover, future expansions of the REIT could still allow the company to strategically maneuver its assets with respect to market directives and growth ambitions. With crucial cash flows driving the company’s current transformations, stakeholders are keenly focused on how management will further leverage its existing cash reserves and solidify its investment foundation.

While Bailian's property arm presents an enticing investment prospect, potential investors must tread carefully, as the retail environment remains convoluted. Ongoing challenges threaten its core business activities and were evidenced in declining performance metrics. The road ahead will depend on management's ability to intersect traditional retail operations with innovative approaches to capitalize on the evolving market landscape.

In conclusion, while Bailian Group commands a dominant position in the retail market due to its extensive asset holdings, the need for a reassessment of its intrinsic value has never been more pressing. As the integration of REITs into its financial strategy could provide vital breathing room, the upcoming quarters will reveal whether this legacy retailer can successfully pivot and enhance operational frameworks. Investors are poised to see how these strategies unfold in light of the volatility in traditional retail sectors and the overarching necessity for reinvention.