In a significant move, the European Central Bank (ECB) has lowered interest rates for the second consecutive time, marking the first back-to-back rate cuts in 13 years. As of October 17, the ECB reduced the deposit facility rate by 25 basis points to 3.25%, with the main refinancing rate falling to 3.40% and the marginal lending rate to 3.65%. This decision comes against a backdrop of a stagnant economy and controlled inflation, reflecting the challenges the eurozone faces today.

The decision raises crucial questions for economists and analysts alike: How should we interpret this latest rate cut? Does the current economic data within the eurozone warrant such a move? And will further rate cuts follow? To unravel these queries, we turn to analyst Li Yingting from the Bank of China Research Institute for insights.

Li highlights that the ECB's decision is a direct response to the recent economic performance within the eurozone. A pivotal factor influencing this decision is the recent decline in inflation rates. Inflation within the eurozone has notably decreased, primarily due to a slowdown in service inflation and a significant drop in energy prices. As of September, the eurozone's harmonized consumer price index (CPI) recorded a year-on-year increase of merely 1.7%, a decrease from the previous month and notably below the ECB's target of around 2%. This marks the first time since July 2021 that inflation has dipped below this target, suggesting that the ECB has some leeway to enact further monetary easing.

Advertisement

To stimulate growth, a decrease in interest rates is seen as necessary. Under current high-interest conditions, demand within the eurozone is sluggish. Consumers exhibit a low propensity to spend while business investment confidence continues to wane, compounded by tight fiscal restraints within the European Union (EU). On the supply side, the manufacturing sector shows signs of fatigue; the purchasing managers' index (PMI) for manufacturing fell to 45 in September, a signal of contraction, while services PMI also dipped below the growth threshold to 49.6%. The economic pressures are particularly pronounced in major economies like Germany and France, with Germany experiencing a continuous decline in its GDP.

Looking forward, Li suggests that the ECB is likely to implement a series of minor rate cuts. This is partly influenced by the U.S. Federal Reserve's recent steep 50 basis point cut, which has widened the ECB's operational space. There's also an urgency for monetary policy change due to the waning performance of the eurozone economy, as maintaining elevated interest rates could risk pushing inflation "too low," counter to the ECB's target.

Rising inflation is only part of the eurozone's economic story; indeed, some analysts warn of the risk of inflation becoming too low instead of too high. Zhao Yongsheng, the director of the French Economic Research Center at the University of International Business and Economics, emphasizes that a low-inflation environment is typical for the EU, noting that a moderate target of around 2% inflation is ideal. He assures that the drop in inflation, currently at 1.8% for September, has been largely a beneficial shift, attributed to a slower demand recovery rather than systemic deficiencies.

Zhao elaborates on the impacts of high-interest rates on industrial growth, explaining that increased borrowing costs dampen growth prospects across various sectors, especially real estate. For years, the eurozone has been burdened by elevated borrowing costs, which inhibit financial innovation necessary for adapting to new economic realities. The ECB's decision, therefore, must navigate a complex landscape, seeking balance between managing inflation and fostering sustainable growth.

As the eurozone grapples with its stagnant economic state, questions loom over the efficacy of rate cuts in reversing the downward trajectory. According to Peng Gang, deputy director of the European Issues Research Center at Renmin University, the ECB’s recent actions are not merely reactionary but necessary measures in light of a global backdrop where the U.S. continues to roll back interest rates. The hope is that by easing monetary policy, the ECB will provide the necessary support for an ailing economy in dire need of recovery mechanisms.

However, an important consideration remains: the impact of geopolitical tensions and other external challenges that the eurozone faces today. With significant uncertainties in the landscape, from military conflicts to global market disruptions, the road to economic recovery is fraught with complexities. As such, in addition to monetary easing, there exists a strong argument for the eurozone to enhance its economic openness, attract foreign investment, and pursue global trade opportunities. A protective stance towards international partners may not only stunt growth but also threaten the euro area’s competitiveness on a global scale.

In this context, the call for economic globalization stands out as a crucial strategy for the eurozone. The EU's current trade policies, particularly those targeting key partners like China, reflect an approach that could benefit from reevaluation. As external markets, particularly those in Asia, continue to expand, tapping into these opportunities could unleash significant growth potential for the eurozone economy that goes beyond mere interest rate adjustments. The critical narrative that unfolds is whether the eurozone can establish a more flexible and open economic framework to pave the way for enduring recovery.